The Old College Try

Once more, local universities take up theater's challenge

University theater is on display this week with a vengeance. Here in St. Louis we have come to rely on area colleges to provide the kinds of challenging offerings that some of our more professional venues tend to shy away from. And more often than not, they're done well.

Certainly, Gary Wayne Barker's haunting Saint Louis University mounting of Federico García Lorca's 1936 tragedy, The House of Bernarda Alba, is as professional a production as anyone could hope for. The baleful story begins on the day Bernarda's husband is buried. The tyrannical Bernarda locks her house and condemns her five young daughters to spend the next eight years in mourning. What ensues is a mesmerizing meditation on women without men. As the Spanish sun beats down, spreading heat through the courtyard, the viewer observes five women in heat, eager to even look at a man.

Lorca, who was murdered during the Spanish Civil War just two months after completing this play, was best known as a poet. Yet he insisted that this script was "a photographic document." If Barker has not staged Bernarda Alba as poetry, he at least has directed it poetically. The dialogue flows with the melodic texture of a verse play (which it is not). The entire cast excels. There is not one single performance for which a viewer has to make special allowance because this is "only a student production." Starting with Katie Consamus, whose totem-pole Bernarda is as rigid as the cane she carries, continuing with the five daughters (Tina Bruna, Nichole Fischer, T. Nicole Kirk, Sarah Price and Lynn Zimmers, who transforms the simple act of cooling herself with a damp rag into a sensual experience) and including Lily Hannan as the longtime housekeeper, this all-female cast is in harmony with Lorca's premise that "to be born a woman is the worst punishment."

Fetching ensemble: The House of Bernarda Alba is a treat.
John Lamb
Fetching ensemble: The House of Bernarda Alba is a treat.


The Seagull and The Nina Variations: By Anton Chekhov; directed by Jason Cannon (Seagull). By Steven Dietz; directed by Deanna Jent (Nina). Performed by Fontbonne University Theatre on alternate dates November 17-20 at the Fine Arts Center Theatre, 6800 Wydown Boulevard, Clayton. Tickets are $10 ($5 for students and seniors). Call 314-889-1425 or visit for a rundown on what plays when.

The House of Bernarda Alba: By Federico García Lorca. Directed by Gary Wayne Barker. Performed by Saint Louis University Theatre through October 8 in Xavier Hall, 3733 West Pine Mall (on the SLU campus). For ticket info call 314-977-3327 or visit

Escape from Happiness: By George F. Walker. Directed by William Whitaker. Performed by Washington University’s Performing Arts Department through November 20 at the A.E. Hotchner Studio Theatre in the Mallinckrodt Student Center at Washington University, 6445 Forsyth Boulevard, University City. Tickets are $15 ($9 for students and seniors). Call 314-935-6543 or visit

Jim Burwinkel's unit set is a marvel of doors and pillars and archways and stairs, and he has lit it with great imagination. At night, the bleached stucco walls reflect distinct colors, as if each hue represents a different daughter: scarlet for one girl's passion, azure for another's yearning. Michele Siler's costumes also enhance the evening's magic. The production runs less than two hours — but the effect of the experience, eerie and hypnotic — lasts a lot longer than that.

Color also plays a pivotal role in Fontbonne University Theatre's staging of Anton Chekhov's 1896 masterwork, The Seagull. To some theatergoers, the very name of Russia's greatest dramatist connotes an evening of gloomy, torpid theater. But good Chekhov is staged in bright, bold colors with movement and humor. There's lots of color here, lots of humor, lots of life.

Set on a lakeside country estate, there are more affairs in The Seagull than in last week's episode of Desperate Housewives. Nearly everyone in this charmed circle of elite gentry is in love, but with the wrong person. Konstantin (Daniel Lanier), a melancholy young writer, is hopelessly enamored of Nina (Rory Lipede), an aspiring young actress. Nina soon finds herself competing with Konstantin's actress mother (Lavonne Byers) for the attention of Trigorin (Charlie Barron), a renowned writer incapable of loving anyone. All this unrequited love, and its ensuing misery, makes up the fabric of the evening. "People are ridiculous," the doctor muses. (There's always a wise doctor in Chekhov's plays; this one is also having an affair.) That sense of the ridiculous is clearly evoked here in a production, directed by Jason Cannon, that can elicit howls of laughter, then turn on a ruble and leave the viewer suspended between breaths.

Terry Meddows portrays the sage doctor with an old-shoe weariness that makes you forget that Meddows is the most facile clown in town. This is the kind of serious clowning that brought Bert Lahr success in Beckett's Waiting for Godot. As the celebrated, if parsimonious, actress-mother, Lavonne Byers delivers a deliciously stylized star performance, both delightful and grotesque, that personifies the human contradictions Chekhov understood so well. No wonder he was the paradigm for dramatists like Tennessee Williams and William Inge.

Fontbonne was wise to import mature guest artists like Meddows and Byers. But The Seagull is essentially a story of the thwarted dreams of the young. This is where the production stalls. The hopeless relationship between Konstantin and Nina never becomes empathetic. The two actors don't even seem to be in the same sphere. Nor have they received much help from their director. Although Cannon stages the first three acts of Chekhov's four-act play (one intermission) in a fluid manner that plays against the depths of despondency to which the story is capable of plummeting, he allows the climactic final act — and especially the final reunion of Nina and Konstantin — to drag out until it's almost too long to bear. Not a wise decision: Actors' shortcomings need to be protected, not exposed.

If you really want to know what that final scene is all about, best to attend The Nina Variations by Steven Dietz, which Fontbonne is staging in repertory with The Seagull. As he has shown in plays like Private Eyes, Dietz loves tinkering with form and structure. And he clearly loves Chekhov. Here Dietz has contrived a 75-minute homage, in which Nina and Konstantin act out 43 alternate endings. One senses that such a conceit might become tedious when the play is produced on its own, as it usually is. But here, directed by RFT theater critic Deanna Jent and staged in tandem with The Seagull, The Nina Variations becomes more than a mere chaser: It clarifies confusions about — and actually completes — the full-length play.

Next Page »