Should heroin addicts be prosecuted for murder? Readers say no.

FEATURE, AUGUST 4, 2011
JAILING THE JUNKIE
Addicts are people, too: Thanks to Mr. Tucker for providing the real pulse of the human lives involved in this story and for illuminating in very clear fashion how far removed the theory of the law is from the reality of the dramas playing out in the lives of addicts ["Smackdown," John H. Tucker]. There's a tremendous amount of attention to detail — and humanity — in this story, and I am grateful for it. I do hope law-enforcement officials read this story in its entirety. It will go a long way to inform their decision-making.
DW Gibson, via the Internet

Finding scapegoats: Stephen Wigginton's plan to eradicate heroine use in the Metro East is nothing more than a smoke screen designed to allow for political chest-puffing and hide the reality that many Americans and lawmakers do not want to face: Drug addiction is here to stay. Because admitting this reality does not garner votes, further careers or help Americans sleep at night, this law, as well as other drug laws in America, are created for the sole purpose of quelling public fear and showcasing a "get tough" attitude that only benefits those who create them.

While it is easy to find scapegoats, such as Angela Halliday or the dealer of Ben Berkenbile, to take the blame for Berkenbile's death, it is impossible to arrest or make an example of the real culprit: the disease of drug addiction. The only people that have the power to overcome this complicated disease are the addicts themselves. And the only way to reduce the number of heroin (or other drug-related) deaths is through the education, understanding and treatment of the disease — one addict at a time.
Joel Niemerg, St. Louis

Rich man's privilege: Look, it's pretty simple. Don't do heroin unless you have the money to afford it. Poor people should not be doing drugs. Poor people should be trying to get un-poor.

I actually know of a practicing doctor who enjoys heroin. Of course, he's smart and only does it once or twice a month as a treat. He works hard and plays hard, and there's nothing wrong with that. The problem is when you have people who want to play hard and not work at all.

Drugs are a lot of fucking fun — as long you have your life together.
Guest, via the Internet

The Nancy Reagan plan: Sad that people need that stuff — any stuff, really. Pot, alcohol, whatever. What is wrong with people? I have to say that although Nancy Reagan was not a favorite of mine, "Just Say No" to drugs seems like a too easy but effective way to combat the market-driven drug trade. It could then totally eliminate the prostitution trade. It would end gang activity. St. Louis wouldn't be in the top ten for the murder rate. Is anyone listening?

I am not saying I have never done drugs; I, too, was influenced by a bad lover and did this. I was lucky; I didn't care for it. So I guess all I can say is buyer beware. You mess around with this crap, and hopefully no one dies. Hopefully you will wisen up sooner than later, and hopefully my kids won't be as stupid as I was.
222coffee, via the Internet

Buried alive: Excellent story. Angela Halliday obviously needs and deserves drug treatment over incarceration. More than 60,000 dead in Vietnam for nothing, and no one went to prison, but the big bad prosecutor wants to bury alive some miserable victim of society over an accidental death of her best friend? It sucks.
Danieljoeoconnor, via the Internet

The land of lawyers: This is no different than suing McDonald's because you spill hot coffee on yourself. What ever happened to self-accountability? Did the provider hold the person down and force it upon him? No. He chose to inject himself.

It's time we start being accountable for our own actions across all levels and quit making so many lawyers so rich — which, by the way, does absolutely nothing for the economy (they assist in changing money from one hand to another and taking a cut themselves).
Joe, via the Internet

 
My Voice Nation Help
13 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
iwantchange5502
iwantchange5502

I grew up with Angela Halliday (from a Christian elementary school through public high school) I myself have struggled with addiction and know know utterly consumed a person can become with the drug. The State's Attorney's can say, " if we scare the shit out of these "junkies" then maybe they'll stop." That is a futile approach to an epidemic that should be given more of a preventative approach. You are not going to scare a heroin addict out of 'dope sickness'. When a person is in such a state they think of little else, but to quench that hunger inside themselves that rips every bit of them. I am from the St. Louis Metro-East area and take this horrible social depravity personally. I have lost friends and family to this, and it is but by the grace of God that I am in the position I am in today. I recall elementary school; listening to our D.A.R.E. officer making references to drugs with some non-threatening stuffed animal and would think,' what is this guy talking about? It almost seems kind of fun to 'experiment' with these things that s/he says not too." I'm telling you... PREVENT drug use SERIOUSLY!!! Stop wasting every taxpayer's money with litigation.. YOU WHO DO NOT KNOW WHAT IT'S LIKE TO BE A HABITUAL DRUG USER CANNOT POSSIBLY KNOW HOW TO STOP THIS EPIDEMIC... GET A FUCKING CLUE!!!

Rosasharon333
Rosasharon333

Addicts can get disability money for addiction. That is not right. Why should those who work hard to pay a mortgage, car note, kids' expenses, fund their own retirement, and otherwise be upstanding citizens have to pay disability, not to mention all the costs of law enforcement, prosecution, and jailing drug users?

Some addicts have gotten that way, we are told on TV and in movies, by being kidnapped, shot up, then forced to do prostitution, theft, burglary, robbery, forgery, write bad checks, and so on to support a habit that they did not voluntarily take upon themselves. These people deserve rehab, humane rehab and restoration - which I'm not even sure is possible.

Those who bring it upon themselves or force it upon others do not, IMHO. Maybe once.

The best thing to do is to either legalize all drugs, thus ending the crime aspects of the drug way of life, or give the death penalty for sellers, users, everyone involved.

I just don't see any other way to deal with this mess, which I have heard about my entire life and I'm now up in years. I know of too many children who are raised by other than their parents because the parents are dead or locked up or otherwise absent, largely due to drugs. I have seen babies born addicted to crack or to heroin or morphine and it is horrible to see these innocents suffering - not to mention the cost of caring for them, which we taxpayers, we idiots pay.

It's hard times financially. Why don't we, as a society, say enough is enough and take off the kids gloves when dealing with the problem of drugs?

As for a doctor who uses, dear God. I know there are people who can use only occasionally like that, but who wants to be cared for by a drug addict doctor? Imagine having your life or the well-being of your loved ones in his hands. As if hospitals aren't dangerous enough, now there's this to worry about.

Mrjr54
Mrjr54

Personal accountability prevails - end of story ! The socially acceptable and judiciary promoted revolving door of rehab is now presented as a license to kill ? How about issuing a tall tree and a short rope to the offender and rid society of the gutter monkey mentality and behavior.

Jennie Harrington
Jennie Harrington

junkies will do anythiing 4 a dolla.... roll over, play dead!!!!

D.Fitz
D.Fitz

Addiction whether it be drugs or alcohol should be treated as a crime if the person is convicted of that crime while under the influence of it, to the fullest extent of the law. There is no reason why they need to be out in public while under the influence but they CHOOSE to do so. There is help out there but they CHOOSE NOT TO GET IT. What is there next excuse for breaking the law? The victims didn't have have choice - they were innocent bystanders who got caught in there addiction.

Rosasharon333
Rosasharon333

I'm not so sure that help is all that available. Funding is always an issue, so is the ability of an addict who is in withdrawal or who is high to get to the source of help.

Addicts need to be locked up and have humane, slow withdrawal imposed. The cold turkey used in jails is criminal IMHO. The only medication given for withdrawal is Clonidine, which is for high blood pressure. It does nothing to control diarrhea, muscle cramping, or sweating and chilling. Watch "The Man With the Golden Arm" with Frank Sinatra to see how horrible withdrawing really is. It's an old movie but very informative.

For truly humane care, an addict should receive small amounts of the addicting substance at certain intervals. The dose and frequency should be slowly decreased and eventually stopped.

Once the addict is free of the substance, they should be forced to attend lots and lots of 12 Step meetings, get some education and job training, stay locked up at least in a halfway house for a couple of years to be given a chance to really start a new life.

Of course, so many run off and if they do run off and start using again as so many do, they should get the death penalty next time they are arrested.

I don't see why society should have to keep paying and paying for their incarceration, rehab, court dates, public defenders, etc. We just can't afford it. A lot of family members of junkies would agree, I think.

Andrew
Andrew

Treat it like what it is - attempted suicide. Let's face it, they are slowly poisoning themselves to death. The fact that it is addictive as well makes it even harder for them to choose to live instead.

Save the 'attempted murder' charge for the people who sell these poisons as 'entertainment'...

susan
susan

Addiction is a disease of choice. You CHOOSE to take that first hit, toke, bite or whatever. Smoking, over-eating, alcohol, drugs...all by choice. If it gets out of hand and you find there really is a problem, there is help available. After you get the help, it again becomes a CHOICE not to touch the substance again. If a crime is committed while on drugs/alcohol, it should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, after all, the victum/s, didn't have a choice but the drunk/high offender did.

Rosasharon333
Rosasharon333

That is not necessarily so - that addiction is a choice.

cupcake
cupcake

Great story !!! I really hope and pray they get it under control. I went to the city jail for three days and all but six of them where on herion. Truly sad. A lot of them where not even 30 years of age. I talked to some of the ladies but they each told me that they would die from it; because they need it, love it, get to sick to get off of it.

 
©2013 Riverfront Times, LLC, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places St. Louis

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city