video of the time-traveling lady
at the Hollywood premiere of Charlie Chaplin's 1928 film "The Circus?"
Check out the video here
. Now, it does really look like the woman is adopting the all-too-familiar posture of someone exchanging inanities with her BFF by phone as she strolls down the street. Irish filmmaker George Clarke made headlines a few days
ago after noticing the segment on the DVD extras for the movie and pointing out how eerily similar her posture was to cell-phone hunch.
But save your jokes about why she can get service in 1928 and you can't
even get it in the damn living room. It's most likely an ear trumpet, an
early hearing aid, according to Philip Skroska at Washington University's Bernard Becker Medical Library
contacted Skroska, who was happy to take a look at the clip and offer an informed opinion.
"If you'd seen that video 30 years ago, it wouldn't have even occurred to you" that it was a cell phone, Skroska tells Daily RFT.
When most people think of an ear trumpet, they think of a huge, cartoonish object
jutting way out from someone's ear. Yet, "most people really aren't that keen on letting people know they have some kind of hearing disability," Skroska says. Even in 1928, he explains, an ear trumpet might have been small and, dare we say it, iPhone-like in proportion.
... Or maybe she was just fixing her hat. Who knows.
If you'd like to take a look at some older hearing devices, check out Deafness in Disguise, the Becker-sponsored Web site that showcases them. You can even take a real-life peek at some of their finest examples at the Missouri History Museum's exhibit, The Americans With Disabilities Act: Twenty Years Later.
Did you see that