Stephin Merritt has come out of the closet: Of course! You're a theatrical composer! It must have been so hard passing as a pop singer all those years
The leader of Magnetic Fields and sundry other indie broods slides into musical theater so easily, you have to wonder how he was ever mistaken for a Brill Building or new-wave revivalist. At their most theatrical, these 26 ensemble recordings (from three productions with director Chen Shi-Zheng) set scenes with charming detail: "We find it necessary to take a spot of sherry, and so we find a very secluded sanctuary," sings a character on "At Madam Plum's." And the characterizations are even more fun, especially the gleeful maniac in "What a Fucking Lovely Day." While the palette, mixing Chinese instruments with echoes of American folk and Tin Pan Alley, bears none of the bombast that makes Broadway so alienating to pop fans, Merritt's preciousness probably has less potential to irk fans of musicals than any other audience subgroup.