The way our panel sees it, North Carolina's got this one in the bag. Here are the results, from worst to first.
University of Louisville
Despite his impressive coaching résumé, Coach Pitino does not go over particularly well with our style mavens. It isn't the clothes -- "They don't bother me," says D-Sly -- as much as the horse they rode in on.
Our panelists even let Pitino get away with the white collar/blue shirt look. (D-Sly: "I don't mind it because he's a definite brunette. If he was silver, no way. If he was blonde, no way.") In fact, they were hard-pressed to point out any fashion faux pas. But appearancewise, Slick Rick draws anything but raves. From the bushy eyebrows to the puffy pallor and the poufy hair, our critics tee off.
Laments Jacob amid the carnage: "Poor thing, we're ripping him apart."
ALISON: "I like the tie, because to me it looks like it has those dot candies on it."
D-SLY: "He needs some manscaping on them brows something fierce."
JACOB: "Those are outta control."
D-SLY: "And maybe some rest: He looks tired."
JACOB: "Or some eye-work, whatever's easier. And some pomade -- his hair's a little fluffy."
D-SLY: "Again, it's the moisturization. I mean he looks like he really could use some skin care."
KATHRYN: "I suggest some cucumbers for over the eyeballs to take some of the puffies out."
D-SLY: "He might want to visit the Grecian Formula."
ALISON: "He does seem to have his nose hair trimmed, though."
University of Illinois
Jacob is torn. On the one hand he has the Illini's Beloved Bruce pegged as "an angry politician who needs some meds." Then again, you can't deny Weber has some fashion sense. "He might be a metrosexual in the sports world," Jacob allows. But the shoes, he says, have got to go.
D-Sly is all over the grooming aspect, noting, "It does seem like he does some manscaping. I mean, if you look at his eyebrows, they're not too woolly-bully. You can tell he's got a good head of hair on him, so that is impressive to me."
The ladies, however, are not impressed. "I'm a captive audience for sports every night," Kathryn reminds us. "The other night when he was screaming into the microphone -- it was kind of a Bobcat Goldthwait kind of a characteristic."
We'll give D-Sly the last word: "Add a watch, pop a Valium, man of my life."
KATHRYN: "An 'A' for the use of orange, because that's not an easy color to use. He pulls his team color off well."
JACOB: "He's expressive, I'll give him that."
KATHRYN: "His hairspray use is all right."
ALISON: Lose the pleated pants: "It's like, 'I could maybe be a little bit pregnant.'"
JACOB: "Bojangles! He looks like he's going to do a little soft-shoe act."
JACOB: "[He needs] some man-bling."
Michigan State University
"I'm getting a very CIA-movie kind of vibe, like he'd be the villain. Like with Tom Clancy, The Hunt for Red October kind of a thing," says Kathryn. "Yeah, very Clint Eastwood," Jacob agrees.
While Pitino's looks do him in, the Izzinator coasts on his appearance, only to be done in by his clothes. "He's very handsome in the bone structure," sums up D-Sly.
But the tie looks cheap, the look's blah, and our man from Michigan State is in dire need of a haircut. "It would make him more youthful," says D-Sly. "Like Dan Rather, when he got his hair cut really short. And all of a sudden he went from looking like 105 to like 60."
D-SLY: "The pants look possibly flat-front or single-pleat."
ALISON: "Which is always better than the double-pleat."
D-SLY: "The tie looks cheap, I have to say."
KATHRYN: "Boring, boring."
JACOB: "I have a little problem with the excess neck skin that kind of like folds over the collar -- he needs a little bigger collar."
D-SLY: "And his jacket's way too big, and there's no tailoring here whatsoever. It's boxy."
ALISON: "He's also missing bling."
JACOB: "Maybe a gold chain or two."
D-SLY: "A gold tooth!"
ALISON: "I see an incisor that needs one."
ALISON: "What do you think of the deep side part?"
D-SLY: "Of course, he's got a receding hairline, but he would youth-anize himself if he got a haircut. He looks like a fit, athletic man, so he should work for his physique versus against it."
University of North Carolina
While Alison observes that the Tar Heels coach has "Presbyterian minister" written all over him, Kathryn begs to differ, opining, "He looks like your favorite uncle that would buy you beer."
"Or an attorney out of, like, Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil," Jacob offers. "I'll bet he's genteel."
But somehow with Roy's vibe it all seems to come back to drinking. "I want to sit down and have a mint julep with him," D-Sly says.
D-SLY: "I love that he's doing a light blue. Love the pocket square!"
JACOB: "I'm impressed with the glasses."
KATHRYN: "Great tan, great tie."
D-SLY: "Well, now, Mr. Man! Welcome to Turkeyville!" (Translation: Consider a neck job, Roy.)
D-SLY: "He's got some type of bling on, although I don't know that I'm feeling the gold, with all this blue-silver-cool tone. I would've gone with more of a silver watch versus a gold watch. Get some ChapStick, clean up your neck, change the watch. If you're going to go with the cool tones, go ahead and deal with that with your hardware."
Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.