Jilly's Ice Cream Bar (8509 Delmar Boulevard, University City; 314-993-5455)
Jilly's Ice Cream Bar is located next door to the original Jilly's Cupcake Bar and Cafe, and it's helmed by the same two chefs, Casey Shiller and Dana Holland Four -- both two-time winners of Food Network's Cupcake Wars. Not surprisingly, an entire section of the menu includes cupcake-inspired ice-cream flavors that contain bits of cake mixed right in, such as the "24-karat" cake with carrot cake and cream cheese ice cream, carrot cake morsels and a cream cheese ice cream swirl topped with sugar-roasted walnuts, toasted coconut and 24k gold-dusted white chocolate shavings. Four different waffle cones are also offered, all made from cupcake batter. Some of the newest ice cream flavors for the year include sopapilla cinnamon swirl and blood orange margarita sorbet sprinkled with lime salt. An expansive list of sauces and "chunkage" toppings includes such indulgences as marshmallow crème, cream cheese icing sauce, ghost chile caramel, toffee bits, Lucky Charms marshmallows and sour gummy worms. Adults, make sure to check out the boozy milkshake menu as well.
Clementine's Ice Cream (1637 South 18th Street; 314-858-6100)
Over the years, Clementine's Ice Cream has collaborated with several chefs at local restaurants to create some truly innovative flavors -- barbecue ice cream for Pappy's, vanilla bourbon with chunks of Kentucky pie for Old Standard, tahini for Elaia, sweet basil with candied ginger for Olio, blackberry cobbler for Cleveland-Heath and gooey butter Cake for Pi Pizza. The small batch micro-creamery will open a storefront in Lafayette Square on May 16: Clementine's Naughty and Nice Creamery. "Naughty" refers to a line of authentically boozy ice creams made with a patent-pending process that freezes alcohol into the ice cream at "levels that will knock your socks off," according to owner Tamara Keefe. The "nice" category is pretty incredible, too, pushing culinary boundaries by combining unique ingredients to make some creations like Madagascar vanilla, strawberry ice cream with balsamic vinaigrette, brown butter candied pecan and chocolate mole. All dairy is sourced locally from cows that are grass-grazed, pasture-raised and hormone-free.
Ices Plain & Fancy (2256 South 39th Street; 314-601-3604)
Building on a technique invented more than 100 years ago, Ices Plain & Fancy is the first ice-cream parlor in St. Louis to offer ice cream made with liquid nitrogen as the freezing agent. Premade ice cream bases are flash-frozen at minus 321 degrees Fahrenheit. After just a minute in a mixer and a nitfy vapor cloud, an extremely silky-smooth ice cream materializes, ready for eating. Seven classic flavors are offered year-round: vanilla, chocolate, mint chip, butter pecan, rocky road, salted dulche de leche custard and cherry cordial, plus rotating dairy-free and soy-free options. Chef Max Crask also creates seasonal flavors like toasted marshmallow campfire s'mores, persimmon, coconut milk key lime pie and Louisiana strawberry (pictured). The shop's newest addition, "Boozy Ices," including the boozy cherry not-so-cordial, are already a smash hit. They offer the same alcohol content as a cocktail thanks to the quick freezing process.
Turn the page for two more amazing St. Louis-area ice cream parlors.
Serendipity (8130 Big Bend Boulevard, Webster Groves; 314-962-2700)
More than 200 unique ice cream flavors are available at Serendipity as a scoop, bon bon, dipstick, shake, cake or pie. Just a sample of the menu's regular flavors include coffee almond, peppermint, Bordeaux cherry, egg nog, cantaloupe, cotton candy and sweet cream. Owner Beckie Jacobs recently collaborated with locally produced Big O to make a ginger liqueur ice cream and with Schlafly for an oatmeal stout ice cream. She also just won "Best Sweet" at Food Outreach's space-themed event, A Tasteful Affair, for her "moon rock bon pop" that combined the flavors of chocolate and orange Tang. Long-time customer favorites are "Cookie Monster" (pictured), Gold Coast chocolate, and salty caramel swirl. Seasonal flavors include Cracker Jack-flavored "Play Ball" ice cream, which is available only during baseball season and King Cake bon bons for Mardi Gras. It's always the perfect season for classic vanilla and chocolate. All dairy at Serendipity is hormone- and antibiotic-free cream from farms in Illinois.
Baileys' Range (920 Olive Street; 314-241-8121)
Baileys' Range is perhaps best known for its juicy burgers and great beer selection. But the menu also includes fifteen not-to-be-missed housemade ice creams. Regular flavors include vanilla, Baileys chocolate, strawberry, salted caramel, cinnamon, espresso, cookies and cream, triple chocolate, peanut butter, white chocolate, raspberry, pistachio, brownie chunk, coconut crunch and a daily special. Specials have included such inventive flavors as three-chili chocolate, mint pistachio, banana Nutella and watermelon sorbet. All are sublime on their own, but can also be whipped into a shake with whipped cream, chocolate sauce and caramel sauce. Or order your scoops in a waffle cone, waffle bowl or as a sundae with whipped cream, chocolate sauce, mixed nuts and a cherry. And yes, this place too offers boozy shakes, such as the "Sweet, Sweet Bacon Shake," which features salted caramel ice cream and Kentucky whiskey and comes topped with a piece of candied bacon.
See also: Ices Plain & Fancy Debuts Ices for Dogs
See also: The 10 Best Dessert Spots in St. Louis
Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club
Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.
Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.
Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.
Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.