Guided by Voices 

Suitcase 2: American Superdream Wow (Recordhead Records)

There's a time-honored complaint about multi-disc releases in which the reviewer indulges the perennial rock critic's fantasy of being a tyrannical producer and claims that any given box set could've been shrunk to one great twelve-song album. But at one hundred tracks, this four-disc odds-'n'-ends collection from the defunct Guided by Voices is just too damned sprawling to accurately condense into one LP. It's a music library unto itself, one that invites customizing. Toss in "A Proud and Booming Industry," a piece of lilting perfection that might be one of maestro Robert Pollard's top-ten tunes, with the supple jangle of a dozen tracks like "Cox Municipal Airport Song," and you've got a great indie-pop album. Lash the Oblivians-like garage of, say, "Shake It Out" to soulful, '50s-ish gems such as "Do Be," and you've got retro heaven. Likewise, there's a better psych album in here than you're likely to find as a dusty reissue; there's beer-chugging, '70s-rock grandeur; there's scuzzy punk; and there's plenty of bracing, experimental noise. Unfortunately for those of us who would take the producer fantasy to its conclusion, however, there's also a consistent current of tape hiss, registering at varying levels from track to track. Then again, you can't have everything for 40 lousy bucks, can you?

Speaking of Review, Robert Pollard

More by Andrew Marcus

Best Things to Do In St. Louis

Newsletters

Never miss a beat

Sign Up Now

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.

© 2017 Riverfront Times

Website powered by Foundation